$12.6 trillion in outstanding US mortgage debt.

Source: Federal Reserve, Q4 2024

Your servicer determines what happens when something goes wrong.

RANKINGS · MORTGAGE

Mortgage Complaint Rates

Mortgage servicers and originators ranked by complaint rate. High complaint rates here often signal servicing failures, escrow errors and wrongful foreclosure practices.

All BanksCredit CardsMortgageChecking & SavingsPersonal LoansStudent LoansAuto LoansMoney TransfersDebt Collection
INSTITUTIONS RANKED
50
of 501 total
CATEGORY AVERAGE
0.07
complaints per 1k customers
BEST PERFORMER
0.00
Servis One, Inc., Titusville, PA Branch
WORST PERFORMER
1.73
GATEWAY FIRST BANK
Not sure if your provider is good enough?See what the data means for you and what to do about it.
⚠️

How to read this table: Ranked from worst (most complaints) at the top to best (fewest complaints) at the bottom. #1 = the institution with the highest complaint rate per customer in this category. Hover the i icons in the column headers for an explanation of each metric.

#iInstitutionRate / 1kiComplaintsiTimelyiRisk Leveli
1
GATEWAY FIRST BANK
1.73/1k
21099%High Risk
2
MIDFIRST BANK
0.49/1k
1,196100%Low Risk
3
EVERBANK, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
0.34/1k
1,26997%Low Risk
4
BANK OF AMERICA, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
0.23/1k
48,15798%Low Risk
5
FIRSTBANK PUERTO RICO
0.13/1k
21698%Low Risk
6
POPULAR BANK
0.10/1k
12399%Low Risk
7
BANCO POPULAR DE PUERTO RICO
0.09/1k
51499%Low Risk
8
BANKUNITED, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
0.07/1k
19499%Low Risk
9
FIRST HORIZON BANK
0.06/1k
39199%Low Risk
10
FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF PENNSYLVANIA
0.05/1k
20396%Low Risk
11
WAFD BANK
0.05/1k
10698%Low Risk
12
HANCOCK WHITNEY BANK
0.04/1k
11498%Low Risk
13
Flagstar Bank, National Association
0.04/1k
246100%Low Risk
14
FIRST UNITED BANK AND TRUST COMPANY
0.04/1k
4796%Low Risk
15
WEBSTER BANK, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION
0.03/1k
198100%Low Risk
16
FIRST NATIONAL BANK OF OMAHA
0.03/1k
74100%Low Risk
17
WESBANCO BANK, INC.
0.02/1k
3797%Low Risk
18
BARCLAYS BANK DELAWARE
0.02/1k
63100%Low Risk
19
UNITED COMMUNITY BANK
0.02/1k
3992%Low Risk
20
COMMERCE BANK
0.01/1k
3997%Low Risk
21
EAST WEST BANK
0.01/1k
73100%Low Risk
22
CATHAY BANK
0.01/1k
22100%Low Risk
23
FIRSTBANK
0.01/1k
19100%Low Risk
24
BANK OZK
0.01/1k
24100%Low Risk
25
CITY NATIONAL BANK
0.00/1k
3097%Low Risk
26
UBS BANK USA
0.00/1k
25100%Low Risk
27
GOLDMAN SACHS BANK USA
0.00/1k
64100%Low Risk
28
Flagstar Bank, N.A.
0.00/1k
3,758100%Low Risk
29
M&T BANK CORPORATION
0.00/1k
3,96299%Low Risk
30
Ditech Financial LLC
0.00/1k
13,629100%Low Risk
31
Seterus, Inc.
0.00/1k
4,275100%Low Risk
32
HSBC NORTH AMERICA HOLDINGS INC.
0.00/1k
4,82597%Low Risk
33
SELECT PORTFOLIO SERVICING, INC.
0.00/1k
14,452100%Low Risk
34
JPMORGAN CHASE & CO.
0.00/1k
25,397100%Low Risk
35
Rocket Mortgage, LLC
0.00/1k
5,39399%Low Risk
36
CARRINGTON MORTGAGE SERVICES, LLC
0.00/1k
5,78299%Low Risk
37
Shellpoint Partners, LLC
0.00/1k
15,00999%Low Risk
38
PNC Bank N.A.
0.00/1k
7,24599%Low Risk
39
Specialized Loan Servicing Holdings LLC
0.00/1k
7,88799%Low Risk
40
NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC
0.00/1k
18,59699%Low Risk
41
Caliber Home Loans, Inc.
0.00/1k
4,31899%Low Risk
42
LoanCare, LLC
0.00/1k
6,71399%Low Risk
43
NEW YORK COMMUNITY BANCORP INC
0.00/1k
1,055100%Low Risk
44
CrossCountry Mortgage LLC
0.00/1k
1,09299%Low Risk
45
Freedom Mortgage Company
0.00/1k
8,100100%Low Risk
46
REGIONS FINANCIAL CORPORATION
0.00/1k
1,11297%Low Risk
47
HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK, THE
0.00/1k
1,045100%Low Risk
48
UNITED SERVICES AUTOMOBILE ASSOCIATION
0.00/1k
98297%Low Risk
49
KEYCORP
0.00/1k
97399%Low Risk
50
Servis One, Inc., Titusville, PA Branch
0.00/1k
1,18897%Low Risk

Mortgage complaints spike after rate cycles - servicers struggling with volume during refinance booms often show elevated rates. Compare servicers before you refinance. Read our full methodology →

WHAT TO DO ABOUT IT
WHAT THIS MEANS FOR YOU
i

A high complaint rate from your mortgage servicer means when an escrow error hits or you need hardship help, you are more likely to face months of runaround.

When your escrow calculation is wrong, when you apply for forbearance during a hardship, or when your payment gets misapplied to the wrong month - your servicer's complaint rate predicts what happens to your home. At the worst-rated servicers, misapplied payments lead to foreclosure threats, damaged credit scores, and months of back-and-forth. At the best-rated servicers, the same errors are caught and corrected within days.

THE FIX
i

You cannot always choose your servicer after closing - but you can choose your lender at origination and you can refinance away from a bad servicer. If your current servicer has a high complaint rate, refinancing can move you to a better servicer AND lower your rate at the same time.

THE DATA
i
HIGHEST COMPLAINT RATE
1.73/1k
GATEWAY FIRST BANK
LOWEST COMPLAINT RATE
0.00/1k
Servis One, Inc., Titusville, PA Branch
  • Servicers with high complaint rates are 4x more likely to misapply your payments
  • Complaint volume spikes 300% during servicing transfers - check your new servicer before closing
  • Best-rated mortgage servicers resolve escrow disputes in days, not months
  • Refinancing can move you to a better servicer AND lower your interest rate simultaneously

Partner links are marked rel="sponsored". ComplaintRate earns a referral fee if you open an account through these links -- at no cost to you. Rankings are independent of commercial relationships and based solely on CFPB + FDIC public data. Read our methodology →

Rate = CFPB complaints ÷ estimated customers × 1,000 · Source: CFPB + FDIC BankFind · Data & pricing